Upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Aylesbury
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
A prisoner complained about removal of a canteen order following an adjudication, saying that although the date of the adjudication punishment had passed, they were still not allowed to purchase canteen.
IPCI reviewed the adjudication paperwork but did not find a start or finish date for the punishment. Further enquiries revealed discrepancies in the dates and timings in the adjudication and when it was processed.
The investigation found that the delay in entering the punishment was not the prisoner’s fault and that the system needed to be reviewed to ensure this does not happen again.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI identified learning to prevent reoccurrence of the same issues, and the Governor was reminded of the importance of ensuring delays do not unfairly disadvantage prisoners.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Swaleside
Complaint category:
Categorisation, progression & release preparation
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
A prisoner complained about a re-categorisation review to Category B. As the prisoner no longer met the threshold to retain Category C status at the time of his review, this element of his complaint was not upheld.
The prisoner also raised concerns about the re-categorisation process. Swaleside was unable to provide evidence that a contribution form and notice of the review date was issued to the prisoner before the review as required by the Security Categorisation Policy Framework. This aspect of the complaint was partially upheld because the prison could not demonstrate compliance with the required process.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI reminded the Governor of the importance of retaining records to demonstrate that prisoners are notified of re-categorisation reviews and given the opportunity to contribute.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor at HMP High Down
Complaint category:
Categorisation, progression & release preparation
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The complaint related to concerns about on-going issues with the prisoner’s offender manager.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI found that using a body-worn camera during an interaction with the prisoner was inappropriate. The staff member was reminded of the correct procedures and apologised. We also identified that inaccurate information was provided in an earlier complaint response and notified the Governor to ensure future responses are accurate. We found no evidence that the offender manager was responsible for delays to the parole hearing, was hindering progression, or was providing ineffective support.
Partially upheld complaint against London Probation Service
Complaint category:
Probation
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The complainant raised concerns about discrimination, misconduct and emotional distress during probation supervision.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI found the stage 1 complaint response was inadequate and did not accurately address all the complainant’s concerns regarding community work and the conduct of their Probation Officer. The responses to the stage 2 and stage 3 appeals were thorough and appropriate. The investigation findings were shared with the Probation Service.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Full Sutton
Complaint category:
Equalities
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner said that delays to fixing his broken rollator amounted to unacceptable care for his disability. IPCI found that the prison did take action to replace the broken rollator, however, more could have been done to expedite the process to ensure the complainant’s mobility was not affected for longer than necessary.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI brought the matter to the attention of the Governor to encourage learning for the future. The rollator had been replaced so no further recommendations were made.
Upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Parc and the Governor of HMP Portland
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner said his property went missing following a transfer between Portland and Parc. Parc failed to send IPCI the necessary documents, including property cards. As a result, it was not possible to determine whether the prisoner’s items were missing or how much compensation was owed.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI recommended that the Governor of Parc ensure the property cards are shared with Portland to enable Portland to investigate and determine which items were missing. We recommended that Parc ensure that staff cooperate fully with IPCI investigations. We also recommended that Portland pay any compensation they owed to the prisoner.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Littlehey
Complaint category:
Accommodation, food, education & other facilities
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner complained that the cleaning fluid used to remove mould from his cell contributed to a deterioration in his respiratory health. The prison was unable to clearly articulate the system in place for staff to report in-cell issues highlighted by prisoners.
Recommendations/outcome:
While there was a lack of evidence to substantiate the complaint about the health impact of the cleaning fluid, there were concerns about the system in place for staff to report in-cell maintenance issues. IPCI asked the Governor to ensure the correct processes are understood and followed by all wing staff.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Frankland
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
A prisoner was allowed to purchase an Xbox 360 while in Frankland. When he moved to Garth, he was not allowed to have it in possession. While the prisoner disagreed with the decision, he indicated he would be willing to dispose of it for a reasonable amount of compensation.
Recommendations/outcome:
Frankland made an offer that was initially rejected, and following IPCI intervention made a revised offer. We hold the view that this complaint should have been resolved by the prison without reference to IPCI.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Garth
Complaint category:
Adjudication & IEP
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
A prisoner complained about the finding of guilt in an adjudication, arguing that the failure to consider CCTV meant the standard of proof was not reached. He also complained the punishment of loss of gym was unfair.
Recommendations/outcome:
While we did not uphold the complaint about the finding of guilt, we did find that the total removal of gym was unfair as the policy framework is clear that prisoners cannot be denied access to this. Prison Rule 29 states that prisoners are entitled to at least one hour per week of physical activity. We recommended the punishment be quashed. We hold the view that this complaint should have been resolved by the prison without reference to IPCI.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Manchester and the Governor of HMP Full Sutton
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner complained that Manchester lost or destroyed his property while clearing his cell after he flooded it. IPCI found that because the prisoner was reckless as to the safety or damage of his property when he flooded the cell, Manchester was not at fault for removing or destroying soiled property potentially caused by the prisoner’s unlawful actions. Therefore, IPCI did not uphold the prisoner’s request for compensation.
IPCI did find that Manchester did not provide a proper paper trail as to the removal of any property and did not respond appropriately to the prisoner’s request for camera footage created at the time. IPCI also found Full Sutton’s response to the prisoner’s confidential access complaint inappropriate.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI recommended Manchester ensure staff were reminded of proper processes with regards to cell clearance and camera footage requests. IPCI also recommended that Full Sutton remind staff of how to answer complaint replies in line with national policy.