Upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Lincoln and the Governor of HMP Leicester
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
A prisoner complained that a large amount of property did not follow him on transfer between Lincoln and Leicester, and that staff were refusing to look into the matter. Lincoln said the property was sent but failed to provide any evidence. Leicester demonstrated no evidence that any of his property was recorded or checked on arrival. Both prisons blamed one another, and left the prisoner to try and resolve the issue.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI upheld the complaint as it was clear that one bag of property with a specific seal number was missing, which matched the contents of the prisoner’s stored property, and reflected the items he claimed were missing. We recommended responsibility for giving compensation be split between the prisons, and the governors remind relevant staff of the need to maintain proper audit trails of transferred property, adopt a problem-solving approach to complaints responses, and liaise with other prisons to try to resolve matters.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Garth
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
IPCI investigated a complaint from a prisoner that staff had not allowed him to purchase a hairdryer or retain his Xbox in possession on transfer. During the investigation it was also apparent that maximum compensation values were detailed on the local facilities list in contravention of the national policy which makes clear maximum compensation values are not permitted.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI partially upheld the complaint as hairdryers were not listed on the local facilities list, despite being listed on the national list as a minimum requirement. We did not uphold the element of the Xbox not being issued as this was in line with national policy. We recommended the prison issue the prisoner with the hairdryer he ordered and amend their local facilities list so that it reflected the minimum requirements of the national list. We also recommended they remove references to compensation maximums.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Sudbury
Complaint category:
Categorisation, progression & release preparation
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner complained that he was returned to closed conditions without sufficient evidence demonstrating an increase in his risk.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI found that staff’s assessment of increased risk was not properly documented, and comments about the prisoner were not supported by available footage. IPCI was not satisfied that the action taken against the prisoner was fair and proportionate or that his actions were properly considered on an individual basis. IPCI recommended: a review of the decision to return the prisoner to closed conditions and confirmation as to whether the reasons for his re-categorisation were accurate; a review of the prison’s process for completing assessments of suitability to remain in open conditions; that the prison provides evidence of any relevant training or briefing on the use of body worn video camera (BWVC) when prisoners are found to be under the influence to ensure a record of their individual behaviours is evidenced; the Governor consider if it would be appropriate to apologise to the prisoner for returning him to closed conditions once the decision had been reviewed.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Coldingley
Complaint category:
Adjudication & IEP
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner appealed against five adjudication charges relating to unauthorised articles found in his possession.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI was satisfied that the charge was proved beyond reasonable doubt and that the process was fair. However, IPCI found that the adjudicator did not record his decision about whether a witness requested by the complainant should be allowed to attend.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP/YOI Hollesley Bay
Complaint category:
Visits, calls & letters
Month investigation completed:
June
Year investigation completed:
2026
A prisoner complained that delays to his mail in Hollesley Bay cost him additional money. During the internal complaints process, prison staff accepted there were delays in delivering prisoners letters but did not take any action.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI asked the Governor to ensure staff handle Rule 39 mail in line with national policy and remind staff to respond to IPCI requests within requested timeframes.
Upheld complaint against the Director of HMP Millsike
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
May
Year investigation completed:
2026
The complainant said that property was lost when he transferred from HMP Millsike to HMP Durham on 19 December 2025, including clothing, a Quran and canteen items. Some clothing was later found at Millsike, but there was no evidence showing what property was retained, or whether and when any remaining items were forwarded or accounted for. While records confirm he had purchased canteen items shortly before transfer, there was no audit trail confirming their whereabouts. There was no evidence of theft, however, Millsike has been unable to account for the retained property in line with policy requirements. In addition, the complainant did not receive a response to his complaint appeal.
Recommendations/outcome:
£30 to be paid to the complainant; the Director to provide an action plan with timescales and evidence of completion; a review of property processes, ensuring accurate record-keeping, and improving complaints handling compliance.
Upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Frankland
Complaint category:
Staff behaviour
Month investigation completed:
May
Year investigation completed:
2026
In another upheld complaint about staff behaviour at HMP Frankland, a prisoner complained he was wrongly placed in handcuffs by a staff member. This was a complex incident connected to a lockdown search of many prisoners. As the decision to handcuff the prisoner had not been recorded as a use of force, it was not subject to the same levels of governance and assurance as a use of force incident. The shortcomings were: the prisoner was left unsupervised in handcuffs, body worn video camera evidence was not recorded, healthcare were not involved, and the prisoner's request for data relating to the incident was not treated as a Subject Access Request (SARs).
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI recommended that the prison: apologise to the prisoner for using handcuffs incorrectly, ensure SARs are properly responded to and take steps to ensure BWVC evidence is retained. We also recommended national guidance should be streamlined to remove inconsistencies, and clearly explain the required actions relating to tier 3 lockdown searches and the role of healthcare.
Upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Whitemoor
Complaint category:
Accommodation, food, education & other facilities
Month investigation completed:
May
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner complained about the failure of kitchen staff to provide food for Hindu festivals at Whitemoor.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI recommended that Whitemoor review the arrangements in place for ensuring that all prisoners are provided with food for their religious festivals, to ensure better communication between the Chaplain and the Kitchen, and to ensure contingency arrangements are in place for when pertinent staff are away from the establishment for any reason.
Partially upheld complaint against the Governor of HMP Channings Wood
Complaint category:
Property
Month investigation completed:
May
Year investigation completed:
2026
The prisoner complained that property sent into him was not issued when it should have been. The prison said he was not permitted to have the property in his possession, so it was placed with his stored property.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI partially upheld the complaint because the prison denied him his property in error. The prison revised their decision and issued the property to him.
Upheld complaint against the Director of HMP Five Wells
Complaint category:
Staff behaviour
Month investigation completed:
May
Year investigation completed:
2026
A prisoner complained about a planned use of force at HMP Five Wells, saying that it was not justified and that his disabilities had not been properly considered.
IPCI found significant shortcomings in the planning and decision-making for the intervention. The prison could not provide records to support the risks relied upon by staff or demonstrate that an individualised risk assessment had been completed. As a result, it could not demonstrate that the use of force was necessary, reasonable and proportionate, or that the prisoner's recorded disabilities had been properly considered. There was no evidence that the use of force was motivated by discrimination or retaliation.
The use of force took place before IPCI had concluded an earlier investigation which identified similar learning around the planning and recording of planned interventions. By the time this investigation concluded, Five Wells had accepted that learning and was already implementing actions to address it.
Recommendations/outcome:
IPCI recommended that the Director provide the prisoner with a written apology for the shortcomings in the recorded decision-making and the absence of evidence of an individualised assessment. As Five Wells was already implementing relevant learning identified through anearlier investigation, IPCI did not repeat those recommendations. Instead, IPCI recommended that the Director provide evidence that the actions had been implemented, including ensuring that future planned interventions are supported by recorded, individualised risk assessments which consider any recorded disabilities.